top of page


Specializing in Personal & Commercial Insurance Services

Welcome to Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance

We’re Here for You When Insurance Matters!

Serving and insuring Michigan residents, businesses, and farms since 1933, the goal at Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance will always be to ensure the satisfaction of our customers. We do that by delivering the right coverage at the right cost with high-touch, personalized service. As a third-generation, family-owned independent insurance agency, we not only serve our customers with unbeatable service, but with a commitment to their claims needs.

Our caring for customers extends beyond our agency and into the community we live in and serve. We support our local community and businesses, especially the farming community throughout Clinton County and beyond. You can trust in the comprehensive insurance products we provide, ranging from home, auto, and life insurance for individuals and families to commercial and farm insurance for business owners.


High-Touch Service

At Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance, we’ve had more than 80 years to perfect the level of service we provide to customers. In addition, we’ve committed to setting ourselves apart from other insurance agencies by creating a separate claims department. What that means is we have a team dedicated to walking you through the claims process. Unlike most agencies, we don’t just give you the phone number to claims departments of the companies we work with.


Commitment to Community

Our commitment to the Michigan community comes from the heart. We’re actively involved in local chambers of commerce and rotary clubs, and Downtown Management. We participate in fundraising activities for local hospitals and fire departments. We also encourage residents to buy local by promoting other local companies in the area.


Focus on Farms

The farming community in Clinton County and throughout Michigan can rely on Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance to deliver superior insurance solutions tailored to its needs. We specialize in farm insurance and know first-hand the types of risks a farming or agricultural company faces in the Great Lake State.

Interested in learning more about our insurance products and services? Contact us today by dialing 989-224-3251 or perusing our website and filling out one of our online forms for more information. We also encourage you to stop by one of our convenient locations in St. Johns or East Lansing.

about us
Discover High-Touch Service for Your Insurance Needs

Understanding that all customers’ insurance needs vary, Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance provides a full line of insurance products and services designed to provide the right protection and coverage at competitive rates.


It doesn’t matter if you are looking for auto insurance, home insurance, farm insurance, business insurance, or bundled plans. Our agents are dedicated to providing an unparalleled level of service that sets us apart.


Trust in us to offer the following personal insurance products and services for individuals and families:

  • Home – including fine art and jewelry coverage

  • Renters/Apartment

  • Condo

  • Rental Property

  • Seasonal Homes

  • Mobile Homes

  • Auto – including high risk

  • Motorcycles

  • Snowmobiles

  • ATVs

  • Recreational Vehicles

  • Boats

  • Life – term and whole

  • Disability

  • Annuities

  • Long Term Care

  • Umbrella

  • Farms

For individuals, families, or businesses who are interested in learning more about their health care options, we also offer health insurance through a referred trusted partner.


When insurance matters, you can count on Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance to be there. We provide high-touch service including claims. That means we have a dedicated  staff to help customers through the claims process. When you need to file a claim, we won’t just hand you a phone number and send you on your way. We’ll actually make sure it gets processed properly. That’s something you won’t find elsewhere.


In addition to personal insurance products, we also provide businesses in Michigan with exceptional commercial insurance coverage, including:

  • Commercial Auto

  • Commercial Property

  • General Liability

  • Workers Comp

  • Umbrella

  • Key Person

  • Life

  • Farm

  • Disability

  • Specialty Products

We specialize in building custom insurance plans for contractors, farms, and manufacturing companies. We understand the risks these businesses face in Michigan and deliver comprehensive solutions at competitive rates.

There will be no sacrificing important insurance coverage for the sake of saving a few dollars. Protection is important. Savings are important. We will work hard to find creative, cost-saving insurance solutions that deliver the coverage you need.

The trusted agents at Allaby & Brewbaker Insurance work hard to form a close, personal working relationship with our clients. We want our customers to view us as insurance consultants and friends because we care about them and about our community.

Contact us today to find out more about our insurance products and solutions. Call 989-224-3251 or complete a quote form for more information.

car parked background house.jpeg
Lansing, Michigan_Aerial View of Downtown.jpeg

St. Johns Office
108 North Clinton Avenue
St. Johns, Michigan 48879
Phone: 989-224-3251
Fax: 989-224-9312

East Lansing Office

330 West Lake Lansing Road
East Lansing, Michigan 48823
Phone: 517-332-3766
Fax: 517-332-7078

Monday - Friday:  8:00am - 5:00pm

For any general inquiries, please fill in the following contact form:

Thank you! Message sent.


bottom of page